Skip to Content
SVB
Silicon Valley Bank
SVB Private
SVB Securities
SVB Capital
Region:
  For a better web experience - please upgrade your browser to Google Chrome  
 
Silicon Valley Bank
Products & Services
Business Banking

Complete your banking transactions with ease and security.

  • Business Checking
  • Business Credit Cards
  • Online Tools & Integration
  • Fraud Prevention
  • Lending
Global Business Solutions

Get customized services to help support your global business.

  • Global Banking Services
  • Global Payments
  • Foreign Exchange Risk Services
Liquidity Solutions

Strategize with our financial experts to help you achieve your business goals.

  • SVB Asset Management
  • Deposits & Investments
Global Fund Banking
Leverage SVB's 30+ years experience in banking top funds.
  • PE Fund Banking
  • VC Fund Banking
Our Expertise
Our Business Expertise
  • Business Stages
  • Startup Banking
  • Venture-Funded
  • Corporate Banking
  • Investors
  • Private Equity
  • Venture Capital
  • Emerging Managers
  • Corporate Venture
Industry Expertise

Our bankers have years of real-world experience to provide guidance across a number of industries.

View All Industries
  • Our Sector Knowledge
  • Cleantech and Sustainability
  • Consumer Internet
  • Enterprise Software
  • Fintech
  • Hardware & Frontier Tech
  • Investors
  • Life Science & Healthcare
  • Premium Wine Banking
Trends & Insights
Trends & Insights

SVB research, blogs and webinars to give your business crucial advantages in decision-making.

Reports Global Fund Banking Outlook Report Healthcare Investments and Exits State of the Markets Report State of the Wine Industry Report Family Office Report Venture Monitor Report View All Reports
Perspectives and Insights Foreign Exchange Advisory Business Growth Market Insights Industry Insights Private Bank Startup Insights View All Insights
SVB Webinars

Register for upcoming live webinars and access recorded webinars to learn about the latest trends for your business and industry.

View Webinars
About Us
SVB Facts

For over 35 years, SVB has helped businesses grow and thrive across the innovation economy

Living Our Values

SVB's values guide our actions, from our approach to supporting small businesses to community engagement to our ESG reporting.

Contact Us

Let SVB experts help your business with the right mix of products, services and strategic advice.

Resources
  • Locations
  • Leadership
  • Newsroom
  • Investor Relations
  • Client Support
  • Careers
  • Success Stories
  • Access to Innovation
Investor News: SVB Financial Group Announces 2022 First Quarter Financial Results Learn more  
PPP
Become a client
Login
SELECT A SERVICE FOR LOGIN
SVB Online Services
SVB Online Services Private Bank Private Banking – Legacy SVB Private Banking – Legacy Boston Private Investments SVB Capital Limited Partners SVB Asset Management Reporting U.S. Bank Pivot Credit Cards Cardholders Administrators Private Bank Elite Card
  • Need help? Client Support
  • Not a client? Apply Now
Search SVB
Products & Services Our Expertise Trends & Insights About Us PPP
Become a client
Login
Products & Services
Business Banking
Business Checking Business Credit Cards Online Tools & Integration Fraud Prevention Lending
Global Business Solutions
Global Banking Services Global Payments Foreign Exchange Risk Services
Liquidity Solutions
SVB Asset Management Deposits & Investments
Global Fund Banking
PE Fund Banking VC Fund Banking
Our Expertise
Our Business Expertise
Business Stages Startup Banking Venture-Funded Corporate Banking Investors Private Equity Venture Capital Emerging Managers Corporate Venture
Industry Expertise
Cleantech and Sustainability Consumer Internet Enterprise Software Fintech Hardware & Frontier Tech Investors Life Science & Healthcare Premium Wine Banking
Trends & Insights
Reports
Global Fund Banking Outlook Report Healthcare Investments and Exits State of the Markets Report State of the Wine Industry Report Family Office Report Venture Monitor Report View All Reports
Perspectives and Insights
Foreign Exchange Advisory Business Growth Market Insights Industry Insights Private Bank Startup Insights View All Insights
SVB Webinars

Register for upcoming live webinars and access recorded webinars to learn about the latest trends for your business and industry.

View Webinars
About Us
SVB Facts
Living Our Values
Contact Us
Resources
Locations Leadership Newsroom Investor Relations Client Support Careers Success Stories Access to Innovation
Select a Service for Login
SVB Online Services Private Bank Private Banking – Legacy SVB Private Banking – Legacy Boston Private Investments SVB Capital Limited Partners SVB Asset Management Reporting U.S. Bank Pivot Credit Cards Cardholders Administrators Private Bank Elite Card
Close
  • Select a Region
    • North America
      • US Main
        Canada (EN)
        Canada (FR)
    • Europe and Middle East
      • Israel (EN)
        United Kingdom
        Denmark
        Germany (DE)
        Germany (EN)
    • Asia
      • China (中文)
        China (EN)
Find anything about our product, search our documentation, and more. Enter a query in the search input above, and results will be displayed as you type.
Searching... Loading content
    Searching... Loading content
    People
    Article Image
    Publisher Logo
    • PRIVATE BANK

    The New Tax Deferral Benefit, Section 83(i). What Executives of Private Companies and Their Board Members...

    • May 22, 2018

    On December 22, 2017, the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act was signed into law and introduced IRC Section 83(i) that could enable eligible employees to defer federal tax obligations on eligible stock from equity grants from eligible companies. 

    In November 2016, we wrote about a similar piece of legislation called “Empowering Employees through Stock Ownership Act (EESO)."  Section 83(i) and its predecessor, EESO, is aimed at addressing the employee’s dilemma of holding stock options in rapidly growing startups without the financial means to exercise and pay the applicable taxes. Employees caught in this decision often feel handcuffed to the company since they would be required to exercise their grants within a short time frame of leaving the firm, but do not have the financial resources to exercise and pay the applicable tax withholding. By not exercising, many grant holders leave hundreds of thousands of dollars in the balance. 

    This article will provide founders, executives and board members of private companies with an overview of IRC Section 83(i) and some things they should consider either before implementing an 83(i) compliant plan or in the event an employee asks about making an 83(i) election on their current grant(s). As always, you should consult with a tax advisor regarding your specific situation. 

     

    Understanding Section 83(i).

    IRC Section 83(i) allows employees to defer federal taxes due on eligible grants for up to 5 years or until a disqualifying event, whichever comes first. The income from the deferral must be included in the taxable year of the disqualifying event or the lapse of the 5 years.

    A disqualifying event is when:

    • the first date the stock becomes transferrable (including to the company)
    • the first date the stock becomes readily tradable on an established securities exchange
    • the date the employee first becomes an “ineligible employee” (see below)
    • the date on which the employee revokes the election

    Only eligible companies may offer the deferment option.

    Start-up and early stage companies depend on equity-based compensation to attract and retain talent. The deferral of income tax recognition following the exercise of stock options or vesting of restricted stock units (RSUs) can be a valuable benefit to employees who may not otherwise have the funds available to pay the taxes at that time. To offer this benefit your company has to qualify.1

    Under Section 83(i), your company is generally eligible if:

    • the corporation’s stock does not trade (and has not traded during any preceding calendar year) on a public securities exchange and; 
    • it has a written plan in place under which, in the applicable calendar year, at least 80% of US qualified employees received grants
    • the stock options or RSUs you award (excepting a combination of the two) are in exchange for your employees’ services and must have equal rights and privileges to receive qualified stock.

     

    Employees are eligible if they:

    • are employed full-time; 
    • are not (and have never been) the CEO or CFO and they are not related to your CEO or CFO;
    • are not a 1% owner of the company during the calendar year, and have not been a 1% owner at any time during the preceding 10 calendar years (this includes equity compensation), or a related party to such owner; and,
    • have not been one of the four highest compensated officers during the current year or preceding 10 taxable years.
    83(i) eligibility

     

    Stock is only eligible for the election if:

    • stock was received from an option exercise or settlement of an RSU; and
    • stock cannot be readily saleable (or that the employee could otherwise receive cash in lieu of the stock)

    Companies are required to have a written plan.

    83(i) mandates companies document that in each calendar year, no less than 80% of US (or US possession) full-time employees are granted stock options or RSUs, with the same rights and privileges to receive qualified stock. This may be a difficult hurdle for companies that are not doing standard refresher grants for their employees.

    The 80% requirement applies separately to RSUs and options and the code defines the determination of rights and privileges to be similar as the manner described in section 423(b)(5). Companies should seek legal clarity regarding these matters.

    Since your existing incentive stock plans do not have language surrounding 83(i), you would have to amend any existing plan in order to comply. Tom Bondi of Armanino, LLP believes “…while existing plans could possibly be amended to include such language, companies should consider shrinking the size of the existing available pool and creating a new 2018 plan that contains the language instead.” This would give the company more flexibility on giving grants that are unique.

    Companies are required to notify employees.

    Section 83(i) requires the company to provide notice to their eligible employees at the time (or a reasonable period before) they become eligible to make an 83(i) election. In addition, the company needs to certify that such stock is qualified stock and inform eligible employees as to the tax impact of making the election and disclose certain tax risks and consequences associated with making the election.

    An election to defer income must be made by the employee no later than 30 days after the first time the employee’s right to the stock is transferable or are not subject to substantial risk of forfeiture, whichever occurs earlier. This generally means the election must be made within 30 days of the issuance of stock following exercise of a stock option or stock settlement of an RSU.

    Expect added withholding and reporting obligations.

    Nonqualified stock options (NQOs) and restricted stock units (RSUs) each present different withholding and reporting obligations. Typically, if an employee exercises an ISO and makes an 83(i) election, the ISO will automatically convert to a NQO and applicable withholding and reporting applies. When employees make an 83(i) election, the federal tax reporting and withholding obligations are deferred. However, state (state tax laws vary and some may be conforming to federal tax law), social security (FICA) and medicare withholding are still applicable.

    For example: If your eligible employee makes an 83(i) election on an ISO, the underlying option will convert to a NQO. As such, at the time of an NQO exercise, you will report the income attached to the exercise, withhold for FICA, medicare and any applicable state tax, and track the appropriate withholding amount for federal taxes. At the time of a disqualifying event, your company will have to remit the deferred Federal and any applicable State tax on the deferred income. Setting up procedures to track payments from participating employees (and potentially ‘ex-employees’) may become complicated. Tom Bondi of Armanino LLC suggests “…companies should plan for time and resources to accommodate these reporting requirements.”

    For example: You grant an employee an ISO for 4,000 shares. At the end of the first year the employee chooses to exercise the option and buys 1,000 shares without making an 83(i) election. Then, at the end of the second year the same employee exercises the option to buy a second lot of 1,000 shares, but this time chooses to defer tax with an 83(i) election. The second exercise of 1,000 shares will now need to be treated as an NQ option grant for record keeping, tax reporting and withholding; therefore, you may expect to have to make manual work arounds, similar to those made on grants exceeding the ISO $100,000 limitations.

    You should be prepared to provide further education to eligible employees to ensure they understand the difference and impact an 83(i) election can make to their tax situation. Educating employees may help them avoid making short-term decisions regarding the financial planning surrounding stock option exercises.

    Company stock repurchases can disqualify employees.

    The new tax law restricts your employees from making an 83(i) election if your company has repurchased any of your outstanding stock in the prior year, unless at least 25% of the total amount of repurchased stock was previously deferred by your employees under the section. The law is unclear if this applies to your company’s right of first refusal (ROFR) on unvested shares. Companies should consult with an attorney and tax advisor to consider how this may impact any repurchases given the current activity in the secondary markets.

    An 83(i) election has risks employees should know about.

    Deferment of income taxes can be a powerful enhancement to your compensation offering, as an 83(i) election can enable your eligible employees to take advantage of options you award without the pressure of immediate tax implications. No matter how the stock performs, your employee would still be obligated to pay any required withholding obligations, including the deferred taxes. Since the taxable amount is fixed according to the fair market value of the stock when the election was made, they could suffer a capital loss if the stock goes down in value after the election. Also, they could find that the tax is due but the shares are still illiquid as is the case of a company going public (taxes are due at the time of the IPO) but the shares are subject to a lockup agreement.

    Next steps? Carefully consider benefit, risks and obligations.

    In addition to the elements described above, there are certainly many things that companies should consider before offering this program to employees. Providing this “benefit” to employees may in fact be a risk that backfires in unpleasant ways for the company and the employee. Companies should begin to educate themselves on Section 83(i) and engage with appropriate experts in advance of employees asking about it. They should be prepared with how to handle an employee making the election without consulting with the company first and delivering the notice to the employer.

    We are happy to have a conversation with you to review the pros and cons of 83(i).


    Additional resources: Empowering Employees through Stock Ownership Act

     

    About Tom Bondi, Tax Partner, Armanino LLP:
    Tom works with early stage technology companies, providing full service consulting and advisory services. As an advisory board member for client companies, he takes a lead role in the positioning of companies during stages from seed funding through merger and acquisition. Tom was a co-founder of a software development company and Chief Financial Officer from its start-up to its acquisition. He also worked in product management for a major Silicon Valley semiconductor manufacturer before entering public accounting. He has served as a board member of many nonprofit organizations and political committees, and has worked extensively in success planning for closely held businesses, stock option planning, interim-CFO services, and estate and trust planning. Tom is a member of the California Society of CPAs and American Institute of CPAs. He has been an advisory board member of many companies and has managed strategic relationships with Silicon Valley accelerators. Tom received his Bachelor of Science in Finance from Santa Clara University.


    Footnote: 1. An 83(i) deferral is not available for equity awards granted by LLCs taxed as partnerships for federal tax purposes. 



    ©SVB Financial Group. All rights reserved. Silicon Valley Bank is a member of the FDIC and the Federal Reserve System. (NASDAQ: SIVB) SVB, SVB Financial Group, Silicon Valley Bank and Make Next Happen Now are registered trademarks used under license. SVB Wealth Advisory, Inc. (member FINRA and SIPC; SEC registered investment advisor) offers brokerage and investment management products and services and is a nonbank affiliate of Silicon Valley Bank and a member of SVB Financial Group.

    The views expressed in the article are those of the person interviewed and do not necessarily reflect the views of SVB Private Bank or other members of Silicon Valley Bank. All material presented, unless specifically indicated otherwise, is under copyright of SVB Wealth Advisory, Inc., and its affiliates and is for informational purposes only. None of the material, nor its content, nor any copy of it, may be altered in any way, transmitted to, copied or distributed to any other party without the prior express written permission of SVB Wealth Advisory, Inc. All trademarks, service marks and logos used in this material are trademarks, service marks or registered trademarks of SVB Financial Group or one of its affiliates or other entities.

    Products offered by SVB Wealth Advisory, Inc.:

    Are not insured by the FDIC or any other federal government agency
    Are not deposits of or guaranteed by a bank
    May lose value

    Neither SVB Wealth Advisory, Inc., Silicon Valley Bank, nor its affiliates provide tax or legal advice. Estate planning requires legal assistance. Please consult your tax or legal advisors for such guidance. Banking services are provided by Silicon Valley Bank, and wealth advisory services are provided by SVB Wealth Advisory, Inc.

    Private Bank

    Related Insights

    • Private Bank December 2021 Outlook from SVB Private Bank Chief Investment Officer Jane Leung December 6, 2021
    • Private Bank 2021 Year-End Tax Planning: 8 Ways To Maximize Your Finances Now Lawrence Crickenberger December 6, 2021
    • Private Bank Don’t Accept “No” for an Answer: Inspiration and Solutions from SVB Step Forward Conversations SVB Private Bank November 17, 2021
    • Private Bank The Attack of the SPAC Lawrence Crickenberger August 26, 2021
    • Private Bank August 2021 Outlook from SVB Private Bank Chief Investment Officer Jane Leung August 19, 2021
    • Private Bank Webinar Replay – Market Commentary with SVB Private Bank Chief Investment Officer July 2021 Jane Leung July 23, 2021

    Subscribe

    Stay up to date on SVB

    Sign up now

    CONNECT WITH US

    Region:
    How We Help Clients
    • Starting Up
    • Venture-Funded
    • Corporate Banking
    • Investors
    • Private Banking & Wealth Advisory
    • Industries We Serve
    Trends & Insights
    • SVB Signature Research
    • SVB Perspectives
    • Success Stories
    • Startup Insights
    About Us
    • Careers
    • Living Our Values
    • Newsroom
    • Investor Relations
    • Leadership
    Contact & Support
    • Locations
    • Client Service & Support
    • Vendor Information
    • Contact
    • Fraud Prevention
    FDIC Logo
    © 2022 SVB Financial Group. All rights reserved. Silicon Valley Bank is a member of the FDIC and the Federal Reserve System. Silicon Valley Bank is the California bank subsidiary of SVB Financial Group (Nasdaq: SIVB). SVB, SVB FINANCIAL GROUP, SILICON VALLEY BANK, and the chevron device are trademarks of SVB Financial Group, used under license.
    Terms of Use • Privacy • Cookies • Help for Homeowners • Corporate Governance • Equal Credit Opportunity Act Disclosures • FDIC • Manage Email Preferences • LIBOR Transition
    You are now leaving Silicon Valley Bank (SVB)
    You will be directed to a different website or mobile app that has its own terms of use, visitor agreement, security and privacy policies. SVB is not responsible for (and does not provide) any products, services or content at the third party site or app, except for products and services that carry the SVB name.
    I understand, let's proceed Stay on SVB.com