Skip to Content
SVB
Silicon Valley Bank
SVB Private
SVB Securities
SVB Capital
Region:
  For a better web experience - please upgrade your browser to Google Chrome  
 
Silicon Valley Bank
Products & Services
Business Banking

Complete your banking transactions with ease and security.

  • Business Checking
  • Business Credit Cards
  • Online Tools & Integration
  • Fraud Prevention
  • Lending
Global Business Solutions

Get customized services to help support your global business.

  • Global Banking Services
  • Global Payments
  • Foreign Exchange Risk Services
Liquidity Solutions

Strategize with our financial experts to help you achieve your business goals.

  • SVB Asset Management
  • Deposits & Investments
Global Fund Banking
Leverage SVB's 30+ years experience in banking top funds.
  • PE Fund Banking
  • VC Fund Banking
Our Expertise
Our Business Expertise
  • Business Stages
  • Startup Banking
  • Venture-Funded
  • Corporate Banking
  • Investors
  • Private Equity
  • Venture Capital
  • Emerging Managers
  • Corporate Venture
Industry Expertise

Our bankers have years of real-world experience to provide guidance across a number of industries.

View All Industries
  • Our Sector Knowledge
  • Cleantech and Sustainability
  • Consumer Internet
  • Enterprise Software
  • Fintech
  • Hardware & Frontier Tech
  • Investors
  • Life Science & Healthcare
  • Premium Wine Banking
Trends & Insights
Trends & Insights

SVB research, blogs and webinars to give your business crucial advantages in decision-making.

Reports Global Fund Banking Outlook Report Healthcare Investments and Exits State of the Markets Report State of the Wine Industry Report Family Office Report Venture Monitor Report View All Reports
Perspectives and Insights Foreign Exchange Advisory Business Growth Market Insights Industry Insights Private Bank Startup Insights View All Insights
SVB Webinars

Register for upcoming live webinars and access recorded webinars to learn about the latest trends for your business and industry.

View Webinars
About Us
SVB Facts

For over 35 years, SVB has helped businesses grow and thrive across the innovation economy

Living Our Values

SVB's values guide our actions, from our approach to supporting small businesses to community engagement to our ESG reporting.

Contact Us

Let SVB experts help your business with the right mix of products, services and strategic advice.

Resources
  • Locations
  • Leadership
  • Newsroom
  • Investor Relations
  • Client Support
  • Careers
  • Success Stories
  • Access to Innovation
Investor News: SVB Financial Group Announces 2022 First Quarter Financial Results Learn more  
PPP
Become a client
Login
SELECT A SERVICE FOR LOGIN
SVB Online Services
SVB Online Services Private Bank Private Banking – Legacy SVB Private Banking – Legacy Boston Private Investments SVB Capital Limited Partners SVB Asset Management Reporting U.S. Bank Pivot Credit Cards Cardholders Administrators Private Bank Elite Card
  • Need help? Client Support
  • Not a client? Apply Now
Search SVB
Products & Services Our Expertise Trends & Insights About Us PPP
Become a client
Login
Products & Services
Business Banking
Business Checking Business Credit Cards Online Tools & Integration Fraud Prevention Lending
Global Business Solutions
Global Banking Services Global Payments Foreign Exchange Risk Services
Liquidity Solutions
SVB Asset Management Deposits & Investments
Global Fund Banking
PE Fund Banking VC Fund Banking
Our Expertise
Our Business Expertise
Business Stages Startup Banking Venture-Funded Corporate Banking Investors Private Equity Venture Capital Emerging Managers Corporate Venture
Industry Expertise
Cleantech and Sustainability Consumer Internet Enterprise Software Fintech Hardware & Frontier Tech Investors Life Science & Healthcare Premium Wine Banking
Trends & Insights
Reports
Global Fund Banking Outlook Report Healthcare Investments and Exits State of the Markets Report State of the Wine Industry Report Family Office Report Venture Monitor Report View All Reports
Perspectives and Insights
Foreign Exchange Advisory Business Growth Market Insights Industry Insights Private Bank Startup Insights View All Insights
SVB Webinars

Register for upcoming live webinars and access recorded webinars to learn about the latest trends for your business and industry.

View Webinars
About Us
SVB Facts
Living Our Values
Contact Us
Resources
Locations Leadership Newsroom Investor Relations Client Support Careers Success Stories Access to Innovation
Select a Service for Login
SVB Online Services Private Bank Private Banking – Legacy SVB Private Banking – Legacy Boston Private Investments SVB Capital Limited Partners SVB Asset Management Reporting U.S. Bank Pivot Credit Cards Cardholders Administrators Private Bank Elite Card
Close
  • Select a Region
    • North America
      • US Main
        Canada (EN)
        Canada (FR)
    • Europe and Middle East
      • Israel (EN)
        United Kingdom
        Denmark
        Germany (DE)
        Germany (EN)
    • Asia
      • China (中文)
        China (EN)
Find anything about our product, search our documentation, and more. Enter a query in the search input above, and results will be displayed as you type.
Searching... Loading content
    Searching... Loading content
    People
    Article Image
    Publisher Logo
    • PRIVATE BANK

    EESO to the Rescue?

    • November 14, 2016

    Employees may soon be able to defer taxes on stock options. But is the new law all it’s cracked up to be?

    Clearly, there’s not a lot of cooperation happening in our government these days. But in September, the House of Representatives passed the Empowering Employees through Stock Ownership Act (EESO). Is this a rare piece of effective bi-partisan legislation that truly helps innovative companies attract talent and allows startup employees a way to cash in on the value they provide their employers? It looks like a good start, but with limitations. Whether you are running these companies or investing in them, it’s important to understand what those limitations are.

    A vexing problem

    The challenge that EESO aims to address has been with us for a while. Many employees at private companies simply can’t afford to exercise their options under current tax law since they trigger a tax hit, either in the form of taxes due at exercise or an AMT (Alternative Minimum Tax) hit. The intent of this new legislation is to enable employees at startups a way to exercise their options and defer any taxes for up to seven years (or until the employee has a way to cash in the stock for value).

    This matters more than ever because many startups are choosing to remain private longer these days. Employees in rapidly growing startups often find it difficult to leave a company because exercising their stock options would create a tax bill well beyond their means. But at the same time, not exercising could mean leaving hundreds of thousands of dollars behind.

    The EESO bill, which could take effect at year-end if passed by the Senate, aims to rectify this conundrum. It sounds like a good start, but let’s consider some of the fine print.

    • One of the requirements is that 80% of the company's employees need to be granted options. In a year where 80% of employees did not receive grants, none of the employee grants made would qualify.
    • There is a reference that all employees must have “the same rights and privileges,” which could be tricky in a start-up environment. Occasionally companies give unique rights to an employee that they are trying to recruit. This could nullify the ability for any of the grants to be “Qualified Grants”.
    • The proposed law requires companies to provide information about the tax impact to any employee electing to defer, particularly in the event that the company’s value declines over time. Should the employee take the election to defer taxes, the company will also be responsible to report the future tax liability on a W-2 for the employee. 
    • And don’t forget, companies don’t necessarily like the idea of making it easier for key employees to switch jobs after a year or so by allowing them to take equity with them. Stock options are a key benefit that’s helpful in attracting talent, but options can also act as “handcuffs” and be helpful in retention as well. 

    Understand the ramifications

    Importantly, employees need to fully understand the risks associated with taking an election to defer taxes. For example, if the company has not gone public or been acquired within seven years of exercising the options, employees could be faced with a large tax bill and no means to pay it. Secondly, the EESO bill will likely only apply to federal income taxes, which means employees are still on the hook for State, Social Security and Medicare taxes. Taking the election to defer taxes would turn an Incentive Stock Option (ISO) into a Non-Qualified Stock Option (NQSO). This may not be in the employee’s best interest depending on his or her individual tax status. Finally, it’s not entirely clear how employees will make this election, other than they will have to indicate within 30 days of purchasing the shares (or in the case of RSUs, 30 days of issuance).

    And then there is the issue of excluded employees. Certain employees may be prohibited from taking this election, including if they have been:

    • A 1% owner, CEO or CFO, or family member of one of these 
    • One of the four highest compensated officers of the corporation at any time during the previous 10 years

    If an employee takes the election to defer taxes and then becomes an excluded employee, they will be subject to the taxation on those options in the year they become an excluded employee.

    Hypothetically Speaking*…

    Everyone loves options. Stock options, that is, can be loved but are also tricky. These potentially lucrative benefits can have eye-popping near-term tax implications for startup employees. Consider a hypothetical scenario where Sally, a brilliant software engineer, decides to execute her stock options (ISO’s) received as part of her compensation package.

    • We assume:
      • The cost of her options is $10,000 and the spread between her cost and the FMV (as defined by 409(a)) is $200,000:
       
    •  
    • The tax bill: 
      • Under the current scenario, Sally would have to pay $10,000 to exercise the stock options, but her tax implication could be as much as $70,000 (via Alternative Minimum Tax--$56,000 for federal AMT and $14,000) for the tax year in which she exercises the options. However, if Sally were able to make the election to defer, the option would become an NQSO and she would only have to pay applicable Social Security taxes (a maximum of $7,347 for 2016) and Medicare taxes $2,900 (plus any additional over the threshold). While that’s not insignificant, the proposed law would allow her to defer the federal withholding of more than $50,000. This sounds great; however, there are still the state tax implications.
      • However, Sally lives in high-tax San Francisco, and she still needs to consider her obligations to the State of California. Under this scenario, she would likely face state tax withholding of more than $20,000. This means instead of paying $10,000 for the options and managing a possible AMT bill of $70,000, she could have to put up over $40,000 to exercise her shares and still owe $50,000 in federal taxes in the future (plus capital gains on any increase in value).
       

    So while this proposed law might be effective in helping Sally, the decision to exercise her options still has ramifications and should be done only after considering her entire tax situation holistically and consulting a tax advisor.


    *The above is a hypothetical example for discussion purposes only with approximations of tax ramifications. Neither SVB Wealth Advisory, nor SVB Private Bank provides tax or legal guidance. Please consult your tax advisor for your specific situation.

    Conclusion

    Ultimately, the EESO legislation may not be a panacea, but it may give more freedom to employees that currently feel trapped by their circumstances. While this could be viewed as an “extra benefit” that is beneficial for startups competing for talent and recruiting new employees, the new reporting and monitoring implications alone might keep younger start-up companies from considering the implementation of such grants.  

    If you'd like to understand how the proposed legislation could make sense for you, or your business, we'd be happy to meet with you. 

    The Fine Print

    This material, including without limitation the statistical information herein, is provided for informational purposes only. The material is based in part upon information from third-party sources that we believe to be reliable, but which has not been independently verified by us and, as such, we do not represent that the information is accurate or complete. The information should not be viewed as tax, investment, legal or other advice, nor is it to be relied on in making an investment or other decision. You should obtain relevant and specific professional advice, before making any investment decision. Nothing relating to the material should be construed as a solicitation or offer, or recommendation, to acquire or dispose of any investment or to engage in any other transaction. Past performance is not a guide to future performance. Opinions and estimates are as of a certain date and subject to change without notice. 

    All material presented, unless specifically indicated otherwise, is under copyright to SVB Wealth Advisory, Inc. and its affiliates and is for informational purposes only. None of the material, nor its content, nor any copy of it, may be altered in any way, transmitted to, copied or distributed to any other party, without the prior express written permission of SVB Wealth Advisory, Inc. All trademarks, service marks and logos used in this material are trademarks or service marks or registered trademarks of SVB Financial Group or one of its affiliates or other entities. 

    ©2016 SVB Financial Group. All rights reserved. Silicon Valley Bank is a member of FDIC and Federal Reserve System. (NASDAQ: SIVB) SVB>, SVB Financial Group, Silicon Valley Bank Make Next Happen Now, are registered trademarks, used under license. SVB Wealth Advisory, Inc. is a registered investment advisor and non-bank affiliate of Silicon Valley Bank and a member of SVB Financial Group.

    Products offered by SVB Wealth Advisory, Inc.:

     

    Are Not insured by the FDIC or any other federal government agency Are Not deposits of or guaranteed by a Bank May Lose Value

    Neither SVB Wealth Advisory, Inc., Silicon Valley Bank, nor its affiliates provide tax or legal advice. Estate planning requires legal assistance. Please consult your tax or legal advisors for such guidance. Banking services are provided by Silicon Valley Bank, and wealth advisory services are provided by SVB Wealth Advisory, Inc (0116-034)

    Private Bank

    Related Insights

    • Private Bank December 2021 Outlook from SVB Private Bank Chief Investment Officer Jane Leung December 6, 2021
    • Private Bank 2021 Year-End Tax Planning: 8 Ways To Maximize Your Finances Now Lawrence Crickenberger December 6, 2021
    • Private Bank Don’t Accept “No” for an Answer: Inspiration and Solutions from SVB Step Forward Conversations SVB Private Bank November 17, 2021
    • Private Bank The Attack of the SPAC Lawrence Crickenberger August 26, 2021
    • Private Bank August 2021 Outlook from SVB Private Bank Chief Investment Officer Jane Leung August 19, 2021
    • Private Bank Webinar Replay – Market Commentary with SVB Private Bank Chief Investment Officer July 2021 Jane Leung July 23, 2021

    Subscribe

    Stay up to date on SVB

    Sign up now

    CONNECT WITH US

    Region:
    How We Help Clients
    • Starting Up
    • Venture-Funded
    • Corporate Banking
    • Investors
    • Private Banking & Wealth Advisory
    • Industries We Serve
    Trends & Insights
    • SVB Signature Research
    • SVB Perspectives
    • Success Stories
    • Startup Insights
    About Us
    • Careers
    • Living Our Values
    • Newsroom
    • Investor Relations
    • Leadership
    Contact & Support
    • Locations
    • Client Service & Support
    • Vendor Information
    • Contact
    • Fraud Prevention
    FDIC Logo
    © 2022 SVB Financial Group. All rights reserved. Silicon Valley Bank is a member of the FDIC and the Federal Reserve System. Silicon Valley Bank is the California bank subsidiary of SVB Financial Group (Nasdaq: SIVB). SVB, SVB FINANCIAL GROUP, SILICON VALLEY BANK, and the chevron device are trademarks of SVB Financial Group, used under license.
    Terms of Use • Privacy • Cookies • Help for Homeowners • Corporate Governance • Equal Credit Opportunity Act Disclosures • FDIC • Manage Email Preferences • LIBOR Transition
    You are now leaving Silicon Valley Bank (SVB)
    You will be directed to a different website or mobile app that has its own terms of use, visitor agreement, security and privacy policies. SVB is not responsible for (and does not provide) any products, services or content at the third party site or app, except for products and services that carry the SVB name.
    I understand, let's proceed Stay on SVB.com