When is a Loan a Gift?

 
Economic Outlook
November 25, 2008 Posted by:
Well you dad-gum government
You better pay attention
You're sittin' up there
Like a fools convention.
- Roger Miller


I am angry. I am frustrated. I am disappointed, annoyed and enraged. All at the same time.

Today, I did something I've advised dozens of friends, family, and clients not to do. I logged onto my brokerage account and looked at my balance. Without going into details, let's just say that knowing the market is down 50 percent is a far different from seeing your actual account balance cut in half. Call it a "coming of age" of sorts.

Over the long run, stocks rise. This is a concept pounded into all of us whether in school, the media or around the water cooler. It's a fact we all know. However, through last Friday, both the S&P and Nasdaq are below the value 12 years ago. I guess the long run is a lot longer than we all thought.

But the deflation of my account balance is not entirely what's got me down - I believe I will eventually recoup all my losses and then some. The real cheery news is the coming bill for all these bailout plans even after they are successful.

Truly, these are not bailout programs at all, but more like investment programs. I believe that over the long run these investment programs will be fruitful both in terms of getting the markets to function again and in terms of returning invested capital to the government, who will then decide whether to pay back the taxpayers. And there you have the crux of the issue.

At what time in our federal government's history did it pay a true dividend back to its shareholders - the taxpayers? None that I can recall.

Once capital invested in firms such as AIG, Fannie, Freddie, the banks (and perhaps soon the auto companies, municipalities, shopping malls, and maybe even luxury jewelers) is returned, my best guess is that some of that cash will be used to pay down debt, but most will be quickly shuffled into new government programs. This may include the provision of newly invented "rights" such as amusement park tickets or pet insurance, perhaps. In any case, using history as a guide, bloated bureaucracies will surely be included.

What if they do decide to pass this return of capital back to taxpayers? Wouldn't this be an excellent time for a little wealth redistribution? If so, I believe the vast majority of ISO readers will be included in the "rich" category, leaving them with paltry "B-class" dividends after having paid the "A-class" price.

The cat is out of the bag now. The government has their hands deep in our pockets and it will be up to us, the voters and taxpayers, to ensure we retrieve our invested capital once its goal has been accomplished. If you haven't already, it will soon be time for you to let your representatives know how you feel.

Comment

Not a Member?
Register now and join discussions in the SVB Professional network. Best of all, it's FREE.

Register Login to Comment

Terms of Service | Privacy Policy